The most feared song in jazz, explained

The most feared song in jazz, explained

Posted by


This is John Coltrane’s Giant Steps.
It’s considered one of the most important jazz albums of all time,
it cemented John Coltrane as a legend among jazz saxophonists and composers,
and it’s home to one of the most one of the most revered and feared compositions in
jazz history. The reason why the album’s title track is
so iconic can be heard in its first few seconds. Coltrane wrote these unique chord changes
for Giant Steps, and later went on to use them over traditional jazz standards. These chords came to be known as the Coltrane Changes — and
improvising over them is considered a rite of passage for jazz musicians. But, if you don’t understand a lick of music
theory like me, it’s really hard to see how this is so legendary. Lucky for me, I know two people that can explain
why… Braxton Cook Braxton: Okay you caught me off guard
there! And Adam Neely Adam: Should I get into the, like, technical jargony
stuff? Let’s cut to the logo first. So there’s a moment in the Giant Steps recording
that really illustrates just how demanding this song is. It happens when Tommy Flanagan, the pianist
on the record, starts his solo. Braxton: The story goes that John Coltrane
brought in the music, he shows up ready to go and then calls he this really fast tempo. Adam: If you hear on the recording, Tommy Flanagan just cannot handle the chord progressions as they’re going by. His improvisation is very halted. Braxton: And Tommy Flannagan’s just holding on for dear life. It really becomes apparent how much he struggled,
when you hear Coltrane take off at lightning speed the second Flanagan stops. Braxton: And then it goes down as like one of the most
legendary recordings of all time. That’s messed up. I’d want another shot. I’d
be like bro, don’t put that recording out. To understand why this was so difficult for
even a highly trained pianist, we need to know three basic concepts and it all starts with this:
the circle of fifths – it’s kind of like a color wheel for music. Braxton: Okay, awesome, you glued this stuff
and everything. This is fire. All twelve notes of the western musical scale
are on it, but you might notice they’re a little mixed
up That’s because they’re organized by a
very special number in music… a fifth. What’s a fifth? Braxton: It’s like if you’re in the C-major scale, you go C, D, E, F, G – right? 1,2,3,4,5. From C to G is five notes, from G to D is
five notes and… well you get the idea. If you play through the circle you’ll traverse
the entire keyboard starting on the lowest C and ending up on the highest C. It sounds much more harmonious than just playing
all the notes in order. That’s because… Adam: The fifth is a sound that our ears just
like. Uh… please explain. Adam: Whenever we’re hearing anything, whenever we’re hearing people sing… Adam: Whenever we’re hearing people play music, we’re
hearing these other notes, these overtones alongside the pitches that they’re playing. When I play this C, the first two loudest tones
that are pushed through the air are both C, one is just an octave higher. But other tones travel to our ears as well. The third loudest is a G, which happens to
be a fifth above C. In 1973, Leonard Bernstein demonstrated this
phenomenon live on a grand piano at Harvard. Listen closely after he hits that note. Bernstein: What do we hear now? That G, right? A new tone. Again, clear as a bell. You want to hear it again? Adam: These overtones are kind of like subliminal tones that you’re hearing alongside a regular note. Adam: And you’re hearing these overtones everywhere. A lot of western music is based on the power of the fifth, especially how it relates so
strongly back to its home chord. Adam: In the case of the key of C major we
have the G chord resolving to C. Adam: And if you’re thinking about what
the G chord represents, it represents kind of tension. You want this to resolve. When it finally does resolve, Adam: it creates this feeling of finality,
it creates a feeling of home. That five to one relationship is present in
a lot of chord progressions, including the most common one found in jazz. The 2-5-1 Braxton:] The 2-5-1 essentially is like the backbone of most jazz music. Even in its most basic form it sounds super
jazzy. So it comes as no surprise the Coltrane Changes
are just chock full of them. Which might raise the question: Why was
Tommy Flanagan caught off guard when he had to improvise over them? Well, the Coltrane Changes aren’t in one
key, they’re in three keys. They’re basically a musical MC Escher painting. So each one of these rungs on the circle of fifths
represents every possible key center. The closer a key is to another, the more notes
they have in common. Like the C major and G major scale – they’re
only different by one note, an F#. Okay, we need an analogy to describe this. Adam: So the way that I like to think about keys is kind of like languages that you have to learn as a jazz improviser. You have to be able to be fluent in a key. Like maybe C is Spanish and G is Portuguese. Those are very similar languages. Adam: If that’s the case, like
okay maybe C is Spanish and you have a distantly related language like maybe Japanese. Let’s say Japanese is B. There’s not much
in common with those two languages. And it’s the same with keys. If you play those scales over each other… It sounds a lot more discordant. Adam: For the most part, most pop music is based around one of these key centers. For instance, Carly Rae Jepsen’s “Cut to the
Feeling” is in A major. But some songs modulate to another key for
dramatic effect. Like Beyonce’s “Love on Top.” Adam: Part of the reason why it’s really exciting is because you’re going to a place that’s really distant on the circle of fifths. And you’re creating a new sense of home.
Which is exactly what “Love on Top” does. But, it doesn’t just happen once, it happens
every time she repeats the chorus towards the end of the song. Adam: And when you chart that sort of thing
along the circle of fifths, patterns emerge. These types of patterns are what fascinated
John Coltrane in the late 1950s and ’60s as he was trying to push jazz harmony to its
limits. This is his study of the circle of fifths. Braxton: I think what makes Giant Steps really special is that it really just, it just documented
an artist doing something super unique, super stylistic, and virtuosic at the same
time. Here’s the first 16 bars of Giant Steps
again, with just the key changes highlighted. If you chart those changes on the circle of
fifths it comes out as a pretty dramatic pattern. That’s because these keys are separated
by major thirds, which divide an octave into 3 equal parts. On the circle of fifths these three keys are
as far apart as possible from each other. Adam: Giant Steps is kind of like you’re
shifting from Spanish to Arabic to Japanese very quickly. By quickly, he means like every two beats
in a song that’s nearly 300 bpm. Adam: It’s not only just like you’re saying
one word per language, you’re having to construct a sentence out of the language. And how does Coltrane make those disparate
languages connect? With one of the most ubiquitous phrases in jazz, the five one. Adam: What he’s doing is taking some of the conventional ideas of tonal harmony, the conventional relationships
between the five chord and the one chord and applying it to this very chaotic circling, sort of chord progression that is the Coltrane Changes. Adam: So if we were all in the same key, it would sound like this. Adam: But because we’re going from key center to key center, it sounds very different. This is why the Coltrane Changes are like
this picture here. Even though you’re seeing things from a
completely new perspective you still feel like you’ve made it home somehow. When Tommy Flanagan saw the charts for Giant
Steps he knew he wasn’t going to just have to play this chord progression – he was going
to have to improvise over it. very quickly. Braxton: That was probably so funny, he was probably like, “What?!” Adam: It is a bit of a rite of passage to
say that you not only can improvise on Giant Steps, but you can also improvise in all 12
keys. Adam: Now, generations of jazz musicians are approaching Giant Steps as the sort of pinnacle of improvisation. Wait. I think I’ve got an analogy for this.
It’s like you’re a cab driver and instead of only knowing one way to get somewhere,
you have to know every back alley and side street just in case. Braxton: It’s essentially like that. You still get to the same location, but it’s really interesting and you might see some really cool stuff in the neighborhood. Braxton: But ultimately I still think the
music boils down to 5 1. People want to come back home. Thanks so much for watching the first of three videos I’m going to release in the next couple of weeks on Jazz. I want to give a special thanks to Braxton Cook and Adam Neely. Between the time that I interviewed Braxton and now, he’s released a full album. Please check it out below and of course special, special thanks to Adam Neely. You can check out his YouTube channel below. Until next time!

100 comments

  1. Love Vox Earworm? Hop onto a live Q&A with Estelle Caswell, the creator behind the series, on December 20 at 5 PM ET by joining the Vox Video Lab, our new membership program on YouTube. She and other creators on our team will bringing you behind the scenes in a completely new way! (And if you missed the livestream, you'd still be able to see a recording).

    You can learn more about the other perks of joining the Video Lab at https://www.vox.com/join.

  2. Beautiful! This is one of the albums that I listened to growing up! My dad was, and is a huge jazz fan, and I never understood why this song was so compelling even though I loved listening to it! Coming back to it all these years later, I can now listen to it with an even greater appreciation!

  3. For me the most difficult about giant steps it’s no the harmony, it’s the rhythm, the places on where the chords are in the progression pfff.

  4. Not intend to offend:
    IMHO I understand how hard it is and how excited the musicians are BUT as a listener I don't find that Coltrane's piece (and humiliating Flannigan) is pleasant to listen. Sorry.

  5. Brava Brava Estelle!!!! Really enjoyed it look forward to your next videos Adam & Braxton are genius! Maestro Coltrane was light years ahead of our time in music!

  6. Okay i got a new information today about jazz and i even search for a lot of sample just to get this deeply. Then i realize i will not get a conversation about this to any of my friends. But yeah worth watching. Love Jazz!

  7. I really like your presentation but, I don't agree with dissing Tommy Flanagan's solo to make your point. That was simply Tommy's style and that was Trane's style. The tune speaks for itself.

  8. HI CULTURE VULTURES!!! DID YOU STEAL ENOUGH OF MY HERITAGE ON THIS VIDEO GO AROUND. HAPPY STEALING, YOU WILL NEVER GET IT AND YOU WILL ALWAYS BE AN UNINVITED GUEST… 🙂

  9. Ok so everyone who doesn’t know what bpm is, it’s beats per minute. A beat last one crotchet, so if a song had a tempo of 60 a beat would last a second. With a tempo of 300 a crotchet would be 0.2 seconds.

  10. Wow – so glad to find this excellent video and video series~! The explanations in this video about music theory are outstanding… as a language buff, I really enjoyed the comparisons of different jazz keys and different languages… thanks Vox and Estelle!

  11. It's like this: you guys write the music and play the songs and I'll just listen and enjoy it! I ain't got time to be sitting around worrying where the middle eight or the fifth is. You guys write the the music and come up with the arrangements and play the song and I'll just sit back and enjoy it. You have your job. I have mine….. How's that for a Straight No Chaser for you?

  12. Great. Fascinating exploration for musicians. I have been apply a few of the lessons learnt. However, using the theory and techniques in real time is way out of my league but something to discuss with my musical partner who is more talented.

  13. Wow, what a cool and educating video. I find comping and improvising on piano an impossible challenge. Surprised to learn that even experienced musicians with great chops can struggle with this.

  14. Maybe if they learn about the flower of life . This describes everything in the universe and how it relates to each other . Color , sound , shapes , elements and mathematics are connected thur a universal language and chart . The symbol that is the flower of life . It all begins with a circle . The circle is the only shape you use and everything in the universe can be found in this symbol . The tree of life and fruit of life .

  15. And this is always why Kenny G is just gonna be a bishhhhhh in the world of jazz.
    He shall and never will be consider a jazz musician in my imo.

    All Kenny Bish G is just person who makes sounds on instrument he doesn't deserve. Go back to your plastic recorder in first grade ya bish.

  16. I always think earworm episodes look so innocent and digestible…
    Nope Lol.
    Don't get me wrong I love them, but they kinda heavy right? I guess you need a degree of understanding about "music theory"…?

  17. The precursor to Coltrane and jazz in general is Ravel and Debussy.
    Listen to Ravel's Pavane pour une infante defunte OR Gaspard de la nuit.

    These two tunes have such imppssible, ALMOST discordant chord changes, one would say it wouldn't work.
    But they are two of my favorite musical pieces. And both create the backbone of jazz theory.
    Good stuff.

  18. This was really well done–I'm saying that as someone who understands music theory pretty well but has always found jazz intimidating. Thanks for putting this together.

  19. This reminds me of the composer Hoyt Curtin and his unbelievable opening theme of Jonny Quest the band had no way of hitting some of the notes as a kid I always loved the opening theme so powerful . please take a listen on you tube I would be interested in any musos take on it …

  20. Okay. 3:23 is haunting, and I don't know why. This feels like one heck of a way to start something. What's going on here? Beyond the fifths.

  21. Watched this video, now my kid is asking where his wooden time telling clock is. No baby, it's mummy's new circle of fifths! 😀

  22. I really can't stand Jazz. It always sounds to me like a couple people on stage trying to prove they are better than the other at playing DIFFERENT instruments, it's like a very argumentative music, there's a harmony of chaos and it sounds too synthetic because of this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *