What If The Sun Disappeared?

What If The Sun Disappeared?

Posted by


Hey, Vsauce. Michael here. Gravity is a property of matter, anything
with mass. This includes the Moon, Earth, Jupiter, the Sun, and even you – your body.
In fact, if you kinda like somebody, have them stand 3/4 of a millimeter away from you.
At that distance, cumulatively, every atom in your body and every atom in their body
will draw you two together with the same gravitational force that the Sun is exerting on you right now. Of course, we don’t feel either of those forces
because compared to the gravitational influence of the Earth, they are basically nothing.
You don’t need to concern yourself with the gravitational attraction between you and someone you’re
hugging, or, your individual body and the Sun, 150 million kilometres away.
In fact, the Sun may as well not exist. What if the Sun disappeared? Well, to be sure, it’s not going to happen.
The Sun will die billions of years from now by expanding, boiling off our oceans
and swallowing the Earth whole. The Sun is not going to simply disappear.
Matter and energy don’t vanish. Of course, matter can quantum tunnel to different locations,
but on the scale of the Sun there is not enough time in the lifetime of millions and
billions of universes for such a probability to even be worth discussing. But let’s discuss it anyway, as a thought
experiment to determine how the Earth would get along with no Sun.
What will the Earth do and what can it do alone? At the exact moment that the Sun disappeared,
we would have no idea. Because it takes light from the Sun 8 minutes and 20 seconds to
reach Earth. So, for a little over 8 minutes after the Sun disappeared, we would have no
idea. Once we did, confusion and mass panic would, most likely, ensue. The Sun’s gravitational grasp on our planet
would also take 8 minutes and 20 seconds to end. This is because gravity waves propagate
at the speed of light. So, the very moment we saw our Sun disappear, we would also lose
its gravitational influence and Earth would fly out in a straight line,
tangent to wherever it was in its orbit. The finite speed of light and gravity mean
that as panic and fear spread across the Earth at the loss of our Sun, we could still, for
a while, look up into the sky and see our planetary buddies, further out, continuing to operate
as if nothing had happened. For instance, Jupiter would continue orbiting
and reflecting light from a Sun that no longer existed for about 30 minutes after the Earth
already knew the Sun was gone. And, depending on where Jupiter was in its orbit, it would
take another 30 minutes to an hour for us to watch the reflected light of Jupiter snuff out. With no moonlight or sunlight, the universe
itself would be our only source of visible light from space. In 2004, Abdul Ahad calculated that the Milky
Way contributes about as much light as 1/300th of a full Moon. So there would be enough light
from space for us to see around a bit. But, of course, electricity and fossil fuels would
still be usable for a while. So, cities and towns could continue to be lit by manmade
sources, just like a typical night; except, it would be night everywhere. Photosynthesis would stop immediately, and
this is huge. I had a great discussion about this video with Henry from MinutePhysics,
and the new channel MinuteEarth. If you’re not subscribed to MinuteEarth, you definitely should be. In one of his episodes there, he mentions
that 99.9% of the natural productivity on Earth is done by photosynthesis, which requires
the Sun. Without the Sun, plants would no longer be able to inhale carbon dioxide and
exhale life-sustaining oxygen. But, don’t worry. Collectively, all of us
humans, all 7 billion of us, breathe in about 6 trillion kilos of oxygen every year.
But our atmosphere contains a whopping quintillion kilos of oxygen. So, even without photosynthesis,
and, including all the other animals, and insects, and microorganisms that consume oxygen,
it would take us thousands of years to run out. The poor plants themselves would be much
worse off. Without the Sun, most of them would die within days or weeks. Except for large
plants. Giants trees, for instance, contain enough sugar for energy that they could technically
live in the dark for years. Their problem is going to be that the Earth will get quite
cold. In fact, mighty trees would freeze to death. Their blood, the water and sap inside
of them, solidify way before they died of starvation. Right now, with our Sun, the average surface
temperature on Earth, hot places and cold places, and different seasons all considered,
is an arguably comfortable 14 to 15 degrees Celsius. Without the Sun to add energy, the Earth would
radiate away heat exponentially, meaning it would go fast at first and then happen
more and more slowly. By the end of the first week without the Sun, the average surface
temperature across Earth would be freezing. Zero Celsius, 32 degrees Fahrenheit.
Now, temperature’s like this happen all the time on Earth, we’re used to it. Panic and fear
and looters and anarchy aside, for the first few days or months, we could get by. But by the end of the first year without
the Sun, the average global surface temperature would be -73 degrees Celsius, -100 Fahrenheit. The best option, really, would be to move
to geothermal areas like Yellowstone or Iceland. These places would be the few safe havens
for human life after the Sun. Nearly all life on Earth exists because of, and is dependent
upon, extraterrestrial energy: the Sun. But the Earth produces its own heat. Despite floating
in the coldness of space for billions of years, down below the crust the Earth is quite warm. 20% of this warmth came from the fact that
when the Earth formed, mass crushed so tightly in the middle that the pressure liquified rock.
The other 80% of Earth’s internal heat comes from that fact that deep in its core,
radioactive elements decay, providing the energy needed to keep the Earth’s core at
5,000 degrees Celsius. Anyone who failed to secure a position within
one of these bastions of warmth, or, perhaps, underground in a community warmed and powered
by nuclear fuel, would likely be dead within the first year of no Sun. In the next 10 or 20 years things would start
to get wet with dew. But not with glorious water droplets. Instead, droplets of liquid air.
The air would literally become cold enough for the gasses that make it up to condense,
or form clouds and precipitate, first as rain, and then as it got colder and colder,
eventually, as snow. In Fritz Leiber’s famous science-fiction short
story “A Pail of Air,” this has already happened. The Earth was ripped away from the Sun, and,
in order to survive, a family must go outdoors in a special suit and scoop up a pale of just
the oxygen snow, bring it back in, and place it over a fire to warm and allow them to breathe. A year or so after the sun disappeared, Earth’s
oceans will have frozen over. Ice all the way across. But ice is less dense than liquid
water, which means that ice floats. And ice is a pretty decent insulator.
So, for billions of years after the Sun disappeared, liquid water could still exist at the bottom of our
oceans, protected and insulated from space by miles of ice above it, and warmed by vents
on the ocean floor that spew water out, super heated by Earth’s interior. This would continue on Earth for a very, very
long time – Sun or no Sun. Instead of becoming frozen and lifeless, extremophiles, like microbes,
that live around hydrothermal vents deep in the ocean, would be fine. They live deep in
the ocean, far below the point where sunlight can penetrate, and they make energy not through
photosynthesis, but via chemosynthesis – converting heat and methane and sulphur into the energy
they need. They are then eaten by clams and tubeworms. Extremophiles deposit minerals back into the
vents, meaning that their food chain is complete. It’s a circle. It’s independent of the Sun.
Earthlings like them would thrive if the Sun were to disappear. They would live just fine
without every knowing that the Sun was gone. Or, honestly, without ever even knowing it
existed in the first place. It’s amazing to think that life, here on Earth,
all alone, flying through space with no Sun, would kind of be fine. Far from becoming a
frozen dead rock, or a boring dormant seed, the Earth would be a spaceship, carrying living
passengers with enough geothermal heat for billions of years of life. If the Sun disappeared, spaceship Earth would
fly out in a straight line covering about 30 kilometres every single second. After just 1 billion
years, it will have covered 900 quadrillion kilometres or about 100,000 lightyears – a trip that
could potentially take it all the way across our galaxy, near thousands of stars.
And nothing’s to say it couldn’t fall into orbit around one, thaw out, and allow its still-living extremophiles
to proliferate life on Earth all over again; maybe one day developing life intelligent
enough to uncover whatever is left of our lives.
Maybe they could even find this very video. In which case, hi, uh, you’re welcome for this video about your planet’s history and journey. And, um, as always, thanks for watching.

100 comments

  1. Maybe if it all unfreezes after so long and life has started its cycle again, when humanity dawns and creates civilization and finally technology, they would THEN have created a computer that can run Crisis on Ultra in 1440p

    But we can only dream.

  2. Buddy, too many mistakes. Fishes alone breath in way more air than we do. Trees without sunlight breath in oxygen and breath out carbon dioxide… The earth flying into space could have unknown effects on the ozone and atmosphere, and without the shield of the sun's radiation we would be exposed to cosmic radiations such as gamma ray bursts which are pretty deadly for all kinds of life… Flying close to another star is more likely to result in a slingshot effect accelerating even more the earth…

  3. What about the sudden change in the planet's direction as we shoot off on our tangent? That would be a very violent event that would probably level most of the stuff on the planet.

  4. Wouldn't the sudden change of direction of the Earth's movement when flying out of the Sun's gravity destroy most of the things on it?

  5. Today I just watched a dream about the sun getting burst like a light bulb 💡 🤪😥
    So I checked on YouTube about the topiccc

  6. You forget to mention that also The earth would not be able to suffer all those meteor strikes, also if the earth might luckily able to visit some other galaxies, but there is no guarantee that it's not gonna crash into some other planet or with increasing time the earth might slow down in its way and just keeps floating around into space ☹

  7. So if the oceans frozen over wouldn’t that mean the sea creatures from the “challenger Deep” would arise from the depths of the ocean considering that it would be so cold everywhere in the ocean and pitch black…. that potentially would give them the chance to kill off the sea creatures living in the upper oceans and throw off the food chain itself 🤔😱!! This would be extremely bad for them in the water!!

  8. Is anyone else somehow reminded of the disney logo by the sun thumbnail? I don't see the words disney or alladin yet somehow get a feeling of the logos being there.

  9. Super late on seeing this one but what would the sky look like if we took off through space like that?? If there’s a video on this let me know but if not you should make a video explaining and showing (if possible)what it would look like. Would be a good one. Anyways great videos

  10. After this the governments need to make bunkers near hot spots and we can also take care of are own plants for oxygen with artificial light/heat lamps and a heat source

  11. Miss you so I will be sure you will have it in myr you want me and i want you want me and i is a good one to go fetch you and go fetch you a couple stuff to do and i want me and I want you and I can meet up at one so you could come and go to the gym then I will be home is a time in the afternoon and then go back and then come to my moms to come over for the kids to

  12. This video depressed me
    By the way a star in another galaxy that's 25 times the weight of our sun just dissapeared into nothing and this was all seen through the Hubble telescope

  13. well… only problem: no humans, no english… have fun discovering dictionaries… you earth-aliens in the Andromeda Galaxy 🌌

  14. If this comment is ever discovered in some sort of future civilization, hello. I am dead now, currently 16 years old and into MX (Motorcross, idk if that’ll be a thing when you’re reading this, but okay) I drive a 2019CRF250R. Driving down with my mom and sister in a Land Cruiser right now. Weird to think one day someone will possibly read this and I will be LONG gone. Odd. My name is Thomas btw. And IF anyone is reading this from the future, you’re cool. I wish I could be there with ya 😉

  15. My "sun" has disappeared into a dimension of subscription services I don't wanna pay for. Sometimes I take a journey back in time, like now, to see glimpses of it again but alas, it is all memories and not like the first time around that "sun" shone upon me. And I never even got the chance to exchange emails (it's [email protected] Michael. Just write me).

  16. What if the earth already lost it's sun and it's orbiting another one and we existed after it………. Just a thought.

  17. How to live without the sun. let God COPY earths core and increase same mass of sun and put the same place where the sun stays, and we all survived.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *